Pinwheel Cookies

$39.00

Calculate Shipping

(26)

An old fashion pinwheel cookie that brings you back to nostalgic times. This cookie is a simple vanilla- chocolate “mild” flavor, not powerful.. with a soft texture in the middle and very slight crunch on end. Red or green sugar crystals are on the sides. Cookies are made by hand. We do not use machines to make our cookies, therefore, no two cookies are alike. If you are looking for a cookie with deep flavor, this is not it.

This listing is for one dozen cookies. Cookies are in cello and then placed in our bakery box tied with a ribbon

Shipping from United States

Processing time

4-5 business days

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I don't accept returns, exchanges, or cancellations

But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.

Frequently Asked Questions

Custom and personalized orders

We definitely will entertain your request for a custom order. Please message us!!

Wholesale availability

Please message us with your inquiries regarding wholesale.

Reviews (26)

Average:

Dec 9, 2025

They were gorgeous! I prefer a crispier cookie. That's why the 4/5.

carol bell

Dec 9, 2025

I received my colorful pinwheel cookies and are very happy that I ordered them. They are exactly like the photo on Etsy shows, very colorful, and they taste delicious as well. The seller took great care packaging them. Each of them arrived in perfect condition. The shipping was fast and the seller followed instructions for when I wanted them shipped to me. I would definitely choose to order from this shop again.

bikini2

Nov 23, 2025

Lake Girl Bakes is absolutely the BEST! I grew up near the Maurice Lenell Cookie Factory and Lake Girl Bakes Cookies taste JUST LIKE the Lenell Pinwheels! Penny has the recipe nailed! Lake Girl Bakes is my ONLY stop for the original Pinwheel Cookies!

Deborah Grubbe

Nov 13, 2025

Lake Girl Bakes delivers an outstanding product! I am big Maurice Lenell Pinwheel Cookie fan since childhood and Lake Girl Bakes makes the BEST pinwheels with great ingredients and ships them with care. This is the second year I have ordered these cookies for Christmas, and I will continue to do so! Way to go, Lake Girl Bakes makes and delivers an outstanding product! Yummy!!!